LIST: 24 recommendations for a second 'Big Brother: All-Stars' season

"Without a shadow of a doubt, Dan Gheesling is the greatest “Big Brother” player of all-time and is definitely one of the best reality stars across any competition reality show. A sheer genius of the game and a competition force, Gheesling played the game like a chess set and truly perfected the use of “pawns.” Gheesling was smart, but never overtly so and that is what made him so enjoyable to watch. Also, who could forget his “funeral.” Perfection."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"To me, Dan is "Big Brother." He knows the game and what it takes to win. If there is to ever be an All-Stars season again, Dan should be the first person casted."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"Although she has never won the game, Daniele Donato is a proven strategist who fights hard. Without a doubt, Daniele is someone who isn't afraid to speak her mind and take on the whole house if necessary."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"While Dani is one of the greatest players in Big Brother history, she has always been in the shadow of her father Dick “Evel Dick” Donato or she is known for her relationship with fellow former houseguest Dominic Briones. A season away from the men in her life would remind everyone of what a truly amazing player she really is."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"If you were to look the people who have won the game and tried to figure out who was the worst, it would be season 19’s Josh Martinez. His win against Abrahamian almost made me stop watching the show. Love him or hate him, Paul is a crazy amazing player and his approach is very unique - he’s a loud mouth with a large personality that rubs people the wrong way, but he’s completely charismatic. He’s the best parts of Dan Gheesling and Rachel Reilly. He deserves a season where the houseguests are not trash."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"My other all-time favorite and probably the best contestant who has not yet won Big Brother."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"While there will never be another Dan Gheesling, Derrick has come very close to matching his master manipulation abilities. While he is worthy of being an All-Star, it would be nice to see him go head to head with some of the best "Big Brother" has to offer."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"Derrick is a genius when it comes to playing the game. He’s extremely reminiscent of Dan Gheesling in the way he is a puppet master extraordinaire and manipulates the players into putting themselves in danger. Granted, his cast was not the brightest bulbs in the crayon box, so it would be interesting to see him play against some intelligent competition."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"By far the greatest player to never win "Big Brother," Danielle Reyes is a force to be reckoned with. As the original master manipulator and strategist, Danielle would be someone everyone would need to be careful of."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"Last year was fairly boring due to a Level 6 power alliance that devastated the house. Robinson was the preppy jock who seemed to be the dumbest person to ever live, but he was playing both sides of the house: making friends with one side, but staying true to his alliance. It was so clever, but he got a little paranoid. I would like to see him, and his face, play the game without having to hide his alliance and true friendships."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Let’s be clear, during last year’s season, I was a Level 6 loyalist. I did not want anyone that was not Level 6 to ever win anything. With that being said, I did like Haleigh and I wished terribly she was on a different season where I could actively root for her." 

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"MY ONE TRUE LOVE. Known for his “friendship” with Ariana Grande’s brother, Frankie, on his season, he is best remembered by his crazy antics such as throwing cereal on fellow houseguests and his love for the Florida Gators. I will never stop loving Zach and while he was not good at the game, he was good for my heart. Fruit Loop Dingus forever."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Da'Vonne is one of my personal favorite houseguests because she says what she means and means what she says. Her quick wit is what makes her fun to watch even when her plans don't always go as well."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"Mama Day is such good television. Besides being evicted in the second week in BB17, she returned for BB18 and made it farther but still not very far. Like other “Big Brother” stars, she has gone on to compete in “The Challenge,” where she has become a better player and proven she is one of the funniest people on television. In a perfect world, an All-Star’s cast would be ruthless, so we need some humor to lighten the game."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Not only is James hilarious, but he is also a strong competitor. As long as he doesn't get involved in a showmance, James could have a real shot at winning the game."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"During her season on “Big Brother,” Natalie was pretty forgettable, except for her relationship with James Huling. However, post “Big Brother” life, she’s become a mainstay on MTV’s “The Challenge. She has learned from the best on how to manipulate friends and she has become a strong competitor. I would like to see new and improved Natalie return to the house."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"One of the most underrated winners of the game ever. Moss suffered from a boring season, and so his win is usually forgotten, but he is a really strong competitor. I would love to see how he reacts and plays the game when he has a lot of big personalities around him. Will he continue to be a major threat or will he play the game quietly? Only one way to find out. Also he liked one of my tweets, it’s probably my greatest moment."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"How could you not have an All-Stars season without Britney Haynes? Not only is she hilarious and has the best line up of gif-able moments, Britney brings the kind of quality commentary the season would need."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"The eye-roll queen. Of all the players ever on this show, I would probably get along with Britney. Her strengths do not lie in quiet manipulation or collections of competition wins, but rather in friendships where she pits people against each other and no one realizes it. In an All-Stars season, there will be many people trying to be the Dan Gheesling of manipulations and the Rachel Reilly of competitions, but the winner will probably be a social master like Britney."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Tyler was the guy from last season I loved, but also slightly hated because he was such a good player. He was able to manipulate and lead fellow houseguests to their exit. How would he stack up against other "Big Brother" power players?"

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"Tyler was the ringleader of the greatest alliance of all-time. Level 6 may have had six people in it, but it was Tyler’s toy. He lied and manipulated everyone, he was responsible for eliminating members of his own alliance and he won almost all the competitions. Not really, but it seemed like it. On paper, he deserved to win the whole game, but he underestimated the power of friendship. Is Tyler that good of a player or is he only as good as his alliance? One way to find out."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Amanda had, what I consider, to be the most obnoxious season of all-time. Like between Elissa Reilly, the worst version of sister and much better player, Rachel Reilly, Helen who is a MomTM and the [offensive] Aaryn Gries, BB15 was a true nightmare. Amanda was too good of a player to have been wasted on this season. Let’s give her the season she deserves."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Kaysar was one of my childhood crushes and I personally would love to see where he is now all these years later. Beyond that, he was a strong player who didn't always make the best calls. However, it would be nice to see him back in the house with other vets like Janelle."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"Before Kaysar, I liked “Big Brother.” It was a fun summer show I would watch with the family and then Kaysar Ridha graced my television screen. Between Ridha and Janelle Pierzina, I became a superfan of the show. Ridha was a great and beautiful player who made some of the all-time dumbest mistakes. I would love to see him return to right some of the wrongs he has made in previous seasons."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Even though she won the online-only season of Big Brother, I have a major ulterior motive for putting Morgan on this list. She was on the most recent season MTV’s “The Challenge” where she was partnered with Johnny “Bananas” Devenanzio and they may or may not be dating now. My sole goal in life is to get Bananas on “Big Brother” and I think this could open the door for him. Also Morgan is an amazing competitor and not annoying or a bad person. She would be really fun in an All-Stars season."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"I loved Cody. From the very start of season 19, he was one of my favorite players because he wasn't interested in anything but winning. Although his romance Jesscia distracted him, he still walked away a winner in his personal life. It would be nice to see him on his own going head to head with other strong competitors."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"I hated Cody. Like, really disliked him. I loved his now-wife, Jessica Graf, but I hated him. However, because of his time on “The Amazing Race” and his relationship with Graf, Nickson is one of the five Big Brother contestants I follow on social media and I have started to actually like him. I would like to see if I would still feel this way when he plays a game away from Graf."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Never afraid to be herself, Kalia was one of my favorite season 13 players. Her partnership and loyalty to Daniele was great to see. It would be nice to see her compete again and step out of Daniele's shadow."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"When he competed alongside Boogie in season 14, I could not stand him. However, when he came back in season 18, Frank started to grow on me. To me, he has the ability to play smart and compete hard. Two things an All-Stars seasons would need."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"For the most part, Jordan is probably the kindest player to compete on "Big Brother." Just don't push her or break her trust in you. It would be great to see her on a season without Jeff and watch who she aligns with."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"Jordan is a total sweetheart, until she is threatened. She was comfortable being in the shadow of her now-husband Jeff Schroeder, but once she was left on her own, her gameplay was able to truly shine. She’s a survivor and she was able to go from target number one to winning the show. She’s kind and in a game where people are constantly stabbing others in the back, Jordan is a breath of fresh air."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Victor is the guy you see from across the room and might think he is so obnoxiously stuck up. Then you get to know him and find he is lovable and loyal. When he was on season 18, it was hard not to crush on El Fit Vic aka the Puerto Rican Sensation. He is a loyal ally and a tough competitor who I would love to see in another season with his fiancé and fellow former houseguest Nicole Franzel."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"I want to like Victor, I really do, but I have not been able to actually root for him… ever. Not on “Big Brother,” “The Challenge” or “The Amazing Race.” Not ever. However, he is extremely loyal and pretty much immune to manipulation. He was true to his alliance and a pretty solid guy. Also, I would like Paul to have a permanent ally so he is not the first one out."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor

"Let's be honest, there would be no All-Stars season with Rachel Reilly. Love her or hate her, she brings the competition to the next level every season she's on."

-- Brandon Peña, editor-in-chief

"First things first: Rachel is probably my all-time favorite Big Brother player. She’s a competition beast, insanely smart, completely ruthless and she targets floaters, aka my least favorite kind of players. Sure she is completely annoying, but I have love her and I have followed though her time on “Amazing Race” to her wedding special. However, I think Rachel’s star is starting to dim and I rather see her quit while she’s ahead. If she did show up, I would still be her biggest fan."

-- Emily Wolfe, executive editor